Please don't do that MTO. They are both very beautiful Black women, regardless of whether they have make up or not. Stop it. There is enough hate and competition out here. And, hating against our own people

It's a toss up, they're both pretty.

they both look dry

what up mto!!!

I'M SORRY BUT MISS KEYS HAS ACNE !!! YOU DO THE MATH !

alicia, hands down. she looks great!

THEY ARE BOTH BEAUTIFUL BLACK WOMEN.

SO MTO, WHY DO WE NEED TO COMPARE AND WHY ARE ALL OF YOUR ARTICLES ABOUT JENNIFER SO NEGATIVE?

AND THEN YOU WANT TO POST HER PIC AGAINST ALICIA KEYS TO RECIEVE MORE NEGATIVE ***. BUT REMEMBER JHUD IS AN ALL NATURAL BLACK WOMEN AND ALICIA KEYS IS MIXED.

They both look good enough to eat if ya ask me!

Alicia is mad nasty. She threw up on her T-*** (see brown stain).

I think they both look beautiful even though Alicia does have a touvh of lipgloss on and Jennifer doesn't

Ms. Keys would get the thorough ***. Hudson needs to find a gym so she can shrink her back fat!

They are both cute without makeout do we really need to vote on this?

Sorry to break this to you but Alicia Keys still has on makeup in those pics. She just doesn't have it caked on like a dead person this time. Is it me or does it seem the less make up Alicia Keys wears, the more white she looks?

-------------------------------------- Save your neighborhoods, START SNITCHING!!!!

I meant make up

both I think!

Alicia has NEVER been attractive to me, not cute, not beautiful. She is so average but I respect that she's classy and talented. JEN HANDS DOWN! Both both of them especially Jen look better w/o makeup, some people just don't need makeup and some do like Beyonce, yeah I said it.

They both look nice MTO.

My money is on Alicia...JHud's complexion is a little off. Maybe if she clears up..then she will be okay.

AKeys.

I'll say both. Hell, they look no different in makeup......just a little shinier.

ALICIA LOOKS BETTER AS LONG AS YOU DONT GET UP TOO CLOSE ON HER PIMPLES.

@ Darknlovelync... I couldn't agree with you more. JHud has it going in many many way as do Alicia and they are both beautiful and talented women. MTO, get a grip.. How's this, Which website do you enjoy most, Perez Hilton or MTO????

Oh please! Alicia by far looks better inside and out! J-Hud would look better if her attitude wasnt so ugly.

THEY BOTH LOOK GORGEOUS!!! NATURAL BEAUTY IS REAL BEAUTY!!!!!

they're both wearing makeup mto...

They both look gorgeous! It's like chocolate and vanilla best of both worlds!

They are both beautiful!!

both look real nice...it's a tie, even though i get the impression alicia has a tad bit of makeup on but it's all good..2 beautiful black , successful women..oh & please ppl,don't turn this into a heated debate based on complexion!

why is it when MTO compare two women they always have a dark skin and a light skin girl

They are both beautiful without the makeup but Alicia took this one.

are u ***' krazy?! Jenni is kool and i'd knock her off just to say i knock'd her off...but Alicia?! wow Alicia is totally gorgeous!

hands down Alicia...so get de *** outta here wit dat one MTO!

Tie, they both look very natural and very beautiful

I have a quick question. Who gives a ***!

both of them look beautiful with or w/o makeup so this *** even be a subject...

This was a stupid post why even post *** like this. This *** aint news.

Alicia is beautiful!

Alicia has an acne problem so she needs makeup to cover up, Jennifer has skin discoloration so they both need some kind of makeup

so wat if she got acne, she still look better than yo *** wiy all tha blemishes

I love her smiley face. Looks cute! Anyone saw her hot albums and videos at the celeb site millionairecupid.com? Hot ans attractive girl.

I've seen Alicia keys, with no make up on! believe me she has make up on in this pic! She has very bad skin. So I have to go with Jhud.

They both look fab to me!!!

alicia of course... she simply has better features and definition in her face. make up or not. :-) Jennifer's face is just big and round for no reason...

modelkiid, is a Alica stan i see.lol lol lol

Truth be told she does have acne thats why she did the commerical for PRO ACTIVE. She's still a very nice looking woman but she needs some kinda foundation to cover up the pimples.

I thought the question was who look better without make-up?

They both look great without makeup.....very natural. Alicia looks so much like someone who would attend the H.S. of Music & Art with us, back in 74. What a great school.

Both of them look beautiful. The ones on here saying they both look busted are the main ones who can't go outside without face paint on! Envy is a sin.....sinners!

How u gonna compare Jennifer Hudson to Alicia Keys? That's like comparing Fantasia to Beyonce. Jennifer will never look as good as Alicia...they're in two different leagues.

Im gonna go with Jenny!!! Alicia is a cute girl too, but I'm representing for all the brown skins out there!!!! ~peace~

i think they look equally beautiful in different ways...they BOTH win!!!

They both look beautiful with out make up They should go with out make up more often.

********************************************** To the world you are nobody, but to somebody you are the world !!

alicia looks better

Are you serious?? Alicia would look better, even if she just woke up with the flu!! youtube.com/themichaelmayshow

this *** even be a story...they both look great without the makeup..why is it necessary to do a comparison between the two women...and plus they both can sang.....

They both are naturally beautiful to me....

Black is beautiful. They both look great. It is unfair to compare and belittle the other.

They both look great. MTO stop trying to start stuff.

ALICIA KEYS looks pale and dull like CRAZY. J-Hudson's complexion really looks great without make up.

IF BLACK PEOPLE WEREN'T SO CAUGHT UP IN DARK SKIN AND LIGHT SKIN THEY WOULD TELL THE TRUTH THAT Jennifer LOOKS the best...their facial features are very similar.

Hello... Alicia is wearing make-up, just no eyeliner! Jennifer has natural beauty that requires little to no make -up at all! Give it up to all the beautiful, healthy, thick chicks!

ALICIA

They both look great.

Gone!

THIS IS NOT ABOUT COMPLEXION. ITS A SIMPLE QUESION. QUIT BEING SO SENSITIVE. ***.

ALICIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm trying to see why Jennifer Hudson and Alicia Keys cannot be compared, as one reader posted.

They are both very pretty ladies, with beautiful voices. They both wear au-natural very well, so it's a toss up.

They both look good without make-up.

Neither. Both should have a little somethin-somethin on cause they never know when stalking-*** media people such as MTO will be lurking around the *** bush. On a side note: J-Hud, stretch pants ain't a good look for you...too much junk in your trunk for that move.

i want to see what the hell yall look like over there...cause i say they both look good

They are both equally beautiful physically, but Alicia can play the hell out of the piano, in all kinds of positions, and she also speaks the King's English and interviews very eloquently. JHud is great, but she's got to let go of that ghetto girl attitude that she displays at every event. Am I the only one who noticed that??? She speaks the same way that she acted in Dreamgirls, ALL THE TIME!!! Not a good look.

This question was ask only to start something. One because there is a light skin women and a dark skin women. Both women are beautiful and both look nice with or without makeup

YOU CANNOT COMPARE THESE TWO WOMEN TO EACH OTHER, ALICIA KEYS IS GORGEOUS IN HER OWN RIGHT AND SO IS JHUD. MTO YOU ARE RE-***.........

Neither one of them needs makeup for real...

they both look nice without make-up.

Alicia still has on makeup

J Hud can GIT IT!!! I'd eat her like a Hershey Bar and then STUFF HER like a Holiday bird!!!!

TWO BEAUTIFUL SISTAH....WHAT IS YOUR PROBLEM FRED? I AM BEGINNING TO THINK THAT YOU ARE JEALOUS OF BLACK AMERICANS,YOU BEING A FUGLY A** BUSH BOY AND ALL. STOP HATING

ALICIA KEYS IS WEARING MAKEUP! U GUYS ARE REALLY GETTING CORNY WITH THE COMPARISON POSTINGS.

They both look beautiful. There is no need to compare the two. That's why it is so hard for some people to make it into the industry because they are always being compared to somebody else.

Keyshia-Mary Rihanna-Beyonce Kelly-Beyonce

They are all beautiful in their own way

That is a stupid *** question, there both queens to me. You should be ashamed of your self and any one that compares the two. Who's the *** that came up with this headline!!

They both are lovely

Two different looks that's like comparing a Range Rover to a 750....yaam sayin' -B.

ANYBODY WHO THINKS J HUD LOOKS BETTER THAN A. KEYS WITH OR WITHOUT MAKE UP IS SMOKIN' BIG TIME. DON'T GET OL' OTIS WRONG, J HUD MY GIRL TO. BUT OL' OTIS LOVE SOME A. KEYS...RIGHT NOW IT'S A. KEYS AND RHI RHI ON TOP IN THE LOOKS DEPARTMENT..

Word @ Japanesefood. Especially for not just screaming, "1st!".

I doubt they walked out their houses without any makeup at all. Regardless, I think they're both naturally beautiful women of color natural.

THey both look nice.

Wow, what a surprise....MTO thinks the big girl is prettier...Shock and awe...lol

I dont even think its close....Nothing wrong with J-Hud, but comparing her to Alicia is like comparing a Ford Focus to a Beamer...One is a nice, steady dependable joint, the other is a luxury model. Alicia is a straight up banger....

How do we know that they both don't have on makeup Again??? OHHH BECAUSE MTO SAYS IT! LOL What up with the 7th grade Who look better game headline?? LMAO Another weak article.

h look cool.like a.keys betta since she calmed down tha GHETTO,DIKEY posin.

MTO, y'all must not have the brightest bulbs in the bunch working for you because they BOTH have on makeup-light makeup, I might add, but it's still there!!

Even though both of these ladies are pretty, Alicia has bad skin, acne to be exact, so there's no way she has taken this photo without some kind of coverage. She may not be wearing any eye makeup, but she's definitely wearing some coverage makeup.

they both ok hell u should see me without make-up

MTO needs to stop now they're both beautiful...alicia still wifey though

they both look like regular black girls without makeup, which is a relief

MTO, stop doing that...

they both look pretty.. lite skin and brown skin and chocolate skin are equally beautiful.

they are both pretty

but i would bang alicia keys 1st since i like lite-skinned women

.......ducks

The both of them look great. There is no win or lose situation.

A.*** Got that! Jennifer looks a little old in the face!

they bkoth look great yo i c^ant c^hoose Bketween em

Stop trying to start some $hit by trying to compare them. Of course you'll get the fools who thrive on dumb stuff like this. They're both beautiful black women.

jennifer hands down..

i really can't stand that "no one" singer.. she's annoying as hell w/ her wide *** hips and ***..

This is so dumb. ALICIA KEYS!

Alicia...but it seem like she got something on though...

They are BOTH beautiful!!!!

They both are purdy...lol

OK let's get real now - M.T.O knows very well that Alicia Keys looks better - just don't wanna admit it but it's the truth.

However, I'm sure Jennifer Hudson is not losing a minute of sleep over it.

NOT A HARD QUESTION AT ALL........(ALICIA) LOOK BETTER THAN HER WITH OR WITHOUT MAKE-UP / LIGHT-SKIN OR DARK-SKIN / SKINNY OR FAT.

They're both gorgeous to me, but I have to go with my soror Alicia!!!

ALICIA KEYS MY GURL

the both look good...j hud god that glow

got*

Alicia, DUH!

Correction, Alicia Keys use to have acne, she doesn't anymore and she always looks beautiful.

I'm goin 4 both! Just the FACT that they BOTH can STILL look good without makeup says A LOT!

They both look great w/o makeup.

They Both do but i think alicia took this one..

MTO NOW YALL NO WHAT EVERYBODY WAS GONNA SAY! STILL TRYNA FIND WAYS TO KEEP PPL COMMING TO THIS RAGEDY *** SITE

Maybe we could start a debate over the ligh skinned vs. dark thing. Or maybe weight, or maybe talent.......

I AM SO PROUD OF THE MAJORITY OF POSTERS WHO DID NOT TAKE THE BAIT!!!!

They are both beautiful in their own right and do not need to be compared to each other. Fred and his gaggle of self hating negro ***'s are race baiting again and it's pathetic! p.s even the untrained eye can see that Alicia IS wearing makeup...so what REALLY was the point in this thread????????????????????????

So dang MTO you must really take your readers for idiots! Anyone who is an Alicia Keys fan knows about her skin problems...but regardless she's beautiful!

I love her and Jen so stop with the BS and REPORT SOME NEWS CAUSE THIS IS NOT... NEXT!

This sounds like some BS we used to do in grade school.

"Do you like me? Circle yes or no and pass it back to me when the bell rings."

Soooo childish, MTO.

They both look like they wearing some make-up so DRAW!

I think Alicia is much prettier than JH. JH has a different look.

I have to agree with the majority, this is b@***!

MTO.... Yall on some serious d@**.

MTO posted this story to start a light skin, dark skin argument!! I'm hip to ya stupid azz Freddie my boy!!!!! Now kiss my brown skin azz! With your dark skin lips!!!!!!

MTO THIS IS SOME DUMB ***! WHAT U WORK FOR WILLIE LYNCH NOW WITH YO DARK SKIN VS. LIGHT SKIN QUESTION? GET SOME REAL NEWS AND STOP TRYING TO MAKE PPL ANSWER THIS DUMB ***!

That is NOT a stain on AK's ***, idiots. if u look at the HQ pic, u'll see that its a tan pattern on the ***

Although A.***. has on makeup in that pic, her acne is cleared up and has been for a while. She has some celeb dermetologist(sp) that her and Rihanna go to(yes RiRi stans she had many a pimple on her forehead) so she doesn't look much different without makeup than she does in that pic since she has on so little.

THEY'RE BOTH BEAUTIFUL WITH OR WITHOUT M.A.C.---JENNIFER'S HAIR IS SO CUTE TO ME....

THEY ARE BOTH BEAUTIFUL BLACK WOMEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They are both beautiful black women

both

actually, they bth look really reallly nice wthout make-up (I HATE MAKEUP!) go girls go girls go girls! ...

They both look fine 2 me.

they both have natural beauty to me...

This is so freakin stupid!! I feel like i'm in grade school, I agree with most... THEY ARE BOTH BEAUTIFUL.

Why are we always comparing our own against each other??? They BOTH look beautiful without make-up. I think the natural and fresh look is always better b/c that shows people that they don't have to paint on an extra face to be beautiful...they naturally are when they roll out of bed.

Both are naturally pretty.

First of there is no use voting. They are both pretty which show that make up dont change much for them and they can still shine without it. Second this is dumb ***. Third to the person at the very top about the (brown stain) boo boo that's a design on her *** cuz its also at the top. MTO didnt say who's outfit is cleaner or better they said without make up. which strictly means the facial area and that goes for anyone else who commented on the clothing...thats the problem with America...can do simple things like answer simple questions........

Thank you blacksapphire!

For telling it like it is.

both ...

@DARKNLOVELY- *** the fcuk up wit that "jhud is a natural blk woman and akeys is mixed" we're all mixed u twit! some show more that others! stop with this not black enough ish! a black women is a black women...PERIOD!

no wonder tiger woods wont claim us, if he did black folks would be on him too.

RACISM AGAINST YOUR OWN IS PATHETIC!

PS...YOUR GRANDKIDS WILL PROLLY BE MIXED...DEAL WITH IT

Imma Have 2 Hand This One Rite Here Ova To My Lite Skin Princezz A.Keyz..Love Love Love Her.

alicia wins this one hands down

BLACK WILL ALWAYS BE BEAUTIFUL! WE CONTRIBUTE THE BEST FEATURES AND SHADES KNOWN TO MAN!

ATTENTION EVERYONE..Alicia has on makeup. She has earth-toned eye shadow on, false lashes, mascara..and blush and lip stick..all in earth tones. Pay attention and look closely.

THEY ARE BOTH PRETTY, BUT JENINFER HUDSON WINS THIS ONE HANDS DOWN!!!!! SHE LOOKS FLAWLESS!!! I LOVE IT!!!! SHE LOOKS SO NATURAL!!!!!!!!!!

both.....

EnchantingDime...

Alicia Keys is half white therefore, she's going to age bad like most of them ( Jasmine Guy for one) so of course JHud looks better. Can't wait for her CD

i think alicia looks better and it ain't got nothing to do star status she just looks better and j hud looks like somebody momma who just woke up

I'd say Jennifer because Alicia does have some make-up on, but they are both very pretty.

MTO yall *** up yall know *** well Alicia look better...no offense to Jennifer...

I'm smart enough to know where they are going with this. They trying to start the whole light-skinned/dark-skinned conflict. Both of them are beautiful women and for the millionth time, a person's complexion has nothing to do with the way they age. Jasmine Guy is aging badly, because of her illness(lupus). Not because she light or mixed. Don't stay stuck on stupid!!!

nothin wrong with either mto. both have clear skin.. ***..

gotta go with keys...no doubt

Of course, I wouldnt be suprise if AK aint gettin much votes because folks fault her, Beyonce, Christina Milian, Rihanna, and others for being Fine *** Red Bones. I pick Alicia because in that pic she look sooo *** fly!!! LOL!

esotericdredz:

Weight comments again, what a loser. They did not say anything about weight, yet your smart mouth a$$ had to say something. Do you wish you were bigger? Bigger D$$***.

They both look great. I'll take me some Alicia Keys tho

They are both gorgeous!

The both look good, but I'm going to have to give this one to Alicia.

enchantingdime is killin down south booty

They're both beautiful, but I'm an Alicia Keys fan, so I'm gonna have to go with her. LOVELY beige woman. :)

They're both sexy but I love me some Alicia Keys.

Now that Alicia Hollered at ProActiv

Also You cant even tell if Alicia got make-up on cuz she so *** white.

Make-up is made for white people. They cant match a real black woman's skin tone as perfect as they do white skin

I will take them both..put me in the middle and baby we got Neopolitian...mmm mmm good

THEY BOTH LOOK CUTE

@nikkiissofun, I was thinking the same thing, he obviously has a issue with weight. Anyway, the "big girl" as he called her is flawless, Alicia has acne problems and her skin will never be a smooth as a all black woman-she is biracial and white womens' skin just 'aint as nice as ours.

Miss Keys of course

I love Alicia but jennifer Hudson is a beautiful BROWN SKINNED BLACK WOMEN!! HER BROWN SKIN LOOKS LIKE BUTTER!!!

@Enchantingdime..so what are you saying?? B/c she's light skinned her skin is prettier?? Well guess what, she has on makeup!! And your not light skinned!!! Even if you wre that wouldn't make you prettier!! Or your skin prettier!! Go on Raiyna's from flavor of Love half naked pics, look at her skin..then look at yours!!

this is some straight up Willie Lynch *** up in here mto laid the trap and yall went for it they are both beautiful women with or without make up big or small. and for you silly a$$ folks that don't know who willie lynch is [link to external website removed]

smarten up ***!$$as

They both look the same but im rockin with my wife ALICIA HATAZ SUCK ***

both are sxy...natural

Jeniffer takes this one coz Alicia stil has make-up on but even if she hadn't, Jen still looks really pretty and would win anyway

The Willie Lynch Speech Is a Fake! It's just another internet hoax. Please do your research chitownj. USE KNOWLEDGE AS POWER to succeed!

They're both beautiful Black women but I'd mash AK like potatoes...

THIS AINT EVEN A COMPETITION...ALICIA GOT THAT!!!

BUT JENNIFER HUDSON IS PRETTY ALSO...BUT ALICIA ALL THE WAY!!!!

Alicia got that that all the way!!!!!!!! Because beauty is natural. If you were stripped down to what you were giving what would these two ladies loose? Alicia-make up. JH-Hair, nails and make up. JH also needs to loss alot of weight she is obese. Maybe she can have gastric surgery. All that weight must stink when being in warmer areas.

the thing with that is, with alicia its such a noticeable difference. not so much with hudson. I'd still smash both though.................................................................................................Alicia first, bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbrrrrr rrrrrrrrr[SPAM]aaaatttttttttttttt

They both look good, stop pounding make up on these woman face. They look so good without make up. On some woman you see them without make up and its like WOLF! Good Googly Moogly!

both

I went to school with Jennifer....lets just say gym class was not her best subject.

LOL@ TO SOME PEOPLE WHO THINK JHUD LOOKS BETTER THAN AKEYS. LMAOOOOOOOOOO THATS FUNNY BUT ANYWAYS SHES CUTE AND WHATEVER BUT AKEYS DEF GOT JHUD BEAT. LIKE SOMEONE SAID IS LIKE PUTTIN FANTASIA UP AGAINST BEYONCE, IT'S NOT EVEN NO DAME COMPETITION. FORREAL MTO THIS WAS JUST STUPID YET IF YOU LOVE AKEYS(AND I DON'T THINK YOU DO) YOU WOULDN'T HAVE MADE THIS BECUASE THE INGNORANT FOLKS ARE SAYING JHUD BECUASE AKEYS IS MIXED. IM DARK-SKINNED AND HELL IM SAYING AKEYS, THIS IS JUST ANOTHER WASTE OF TIME.

NEXXXXXXXXXXT

THEY BOTH LOOK GREAT WITH OR WITHOUT THE MAKE UP, EACH IN THER OWN WAY.

Alicia Keys

They are both beautiful women in different ways, why compare?

MAN! MTO! u guys have showed some pics of alicia that were BUSTED b4, and she had absolutely NO makeup on whatsoever. she has at least a lil bit of somethin' on her face. alicia looks pretty and jen is lookin cute :)

@IM4REALTHO you just missed the whole point it does not matter if the speech is real or not the system that is described in the speech about dividing us is real open up your eyes and you might see that we have been getting played for a few 100 years now.

maybe this will help make things more clear the full speech

http://thetalkingdrum.com/wil.html

They're both beautiful, but I think Jennifer Hudson takes it.. remember when Alicia Keys had f'd up skin? It's clear up A LOT.

Both are naturally beautiful!

I guess Proactiv does work huh, go figure! I think J Hud looks more youthful when she doesn't wear makeup.She's a cute girl anyway. As far as Alicia, she looks very pale but she looks really fresh. Does anybody else think she looks like her eyes are getting "lazier"?

co-sign chitownj this IS some willie lynch b.s. light skin vs. dark skin huh mto? they both fine and can get wifed so stfu superficial self hating mofos!!

willie lynch speech is *** been around about what? 200 fuggin yrs. BEFORE the internet pleaseeeee that sh** still embodied in SOME black peoples minds to this day no she didn't say it's a hoax an INTERNET hoax at that? LMMFAO

ALICIA KEYS

Alicia keys has on light foundation...if u wore make-up u could tell. both look decent though. however alicia does not have *** on jennifer in the voice department.....not even a little bit!

I thought the pics were going tobe all crazy looking, nah they both look beautiful. That's cool.

Uhhhhhh this is so wack cause J Hud aint pretty!!! Sorry MTO but A Keys looks wayyy better!

Ok I must admit, when I read the header for this, I'm thinking to myself "you got to be kidding. ALICIA! Hands down." But now that I see the pics, Jennifer looks absolutely beautiful. Moreso without the makeup. But both women are just strikingly beautiful. Go sistas!!

They both look nice-great skin!

Alicia is wearing makeup in that picture. They are both beautiful, why make it a contest?

i already know what MTO is doing and it is sad and sick in the brain area. alicia keys is wearing makeup. she is pale, almost see-thru w/o it. nothing wrong with her type of beauty, just stop lying.

they both look uggh without make up but they are not ugly

THEY BOTH R BEAUTIFUL WOMEN *** GIVE 'EM A BREAK.

THEY BOTH GET POINTS

First off, they are both wearing a little makeup. Anyway, they are both gorgeous. Yes, we all know that Alicia has some acne issues, and J-Hud is what many would consider to be overweight. So what?! They are both real people and both very pretty. Stop inciting these hate crimes MTO.

not sure about the other, but Alicia looks like she's wearing makeup....