OK, first of all, regardless of who's sick of someone or not, should have nothing to do with whether they deserve to be on a Most Sexy list.
Second of all, I think Bey should be high on the list of black women - which I hear she actually is. Now if we were including ALL women (Latin, exotic, etc), she might be a little further down that list for me. But since it's just black celebs, she definitely should be high on the list.
Halle, I can see how she could wind up #1 on that list because she actually got sexier with age, in my book. To me, she used to be a gorgeous face, but didn't really get me on the sexiness tip. She was more classic facial beauty, but I didn't think *** back then. I *** sure do now, lol. See "Perfect Stranger" to know what I'm talking about.
Gabrielle... I wouldn't put her before Bey. Pretty, yes, but kinda quirky & just an overall cute persona. Nice & all, but... nah.
Beyonce, same *** thing. Her persona doesn't scream sexy either. On the stage, she knows how to ACT sexy, but it never seems like she's really that. That's because her stage persona & her media persona are so opposite. Dunno, just my 2 cents.