This is a forum post by the user confusion-lova

beyonce vs aaliyah

: this whole Beyonce one in a million deal makes me mad.. Beyonce does what she does but she will never amount to Aaliyah.. The song is an original...Beyonce wont do it like Aaliyah did there voices arent the same not even close..In my opinion Aaliyah had way more talent, skill, and heart than Beyonce does..What is your opinion?

Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Share to Email

Comments

standard

I'm so tried of Beyonce already, this is not a good idea she wants to b in everything all the time and its really really getting outa control. She's going to hurt her career if she keeps at it like this. Let Aaliyah's music b Aaliyah's music dead or alive


MrsSJackson

Ugh@ that hag Beyawnce


bdsbabydoll

LOL I don't even know what a stan is, but I guess I'm one. Beyonce can sing me anything! I've always wondered what diff. artists would sound like singing someone else's songs.


1-in-a-million

BEYONCE NEEDS TO FALL DOWN SOME WHERE!


standard

BDSBABY

Don't get me wrong Beyonce is the bomb at what she does but come on u gotta admit this *** is everywhere, even on the *** spanish channels. Then she got that commerical where its like 3-4 Beyonce's, *** i need a Bey Break


bdsbabydoll

I applaud her for making that money! She did say she wanted to retire by the time she was 30, I think.


TheKey

Is One In A Million even old enough to be done over??? I thought it was too soon for Jagged Edge to remake Jodeci's Come & Talk To Me. I love Beyonce but I think she needs to leave Aaliyah's songs alone, that is if the story is even true.


standard

She can retire today and still have millions and millions in the bank, she's overexposing herself big time, ppl gon start booing her like they did Destiny's Child. U gotta take a break, reinvent urself and come back stronger. Madonna stay falling off and coming back bigger and stronger


bdsbabydoll

Jagged Edge did Jodeci? I never heard that. New album upcoming or already out?


TheKey

Jagged Edge and Faboulous did a remix of it, maybe last summer. I think it was DJ Clue's album, I gotta check. The song was ok, but it sounds just like Jodeci's so what was the point?


brown_skin

Bey can do much better than that one in a million song. Let's face facts I loved Aaliyah but beyonce can blow.


bdsbabydoll

LOL @ Standard Then Lawd! You'd be Beyonce'd and Aaliyah'd out at my house. Not to mention you'd be doing that Michael Jackson pelvis pop right along with me, bc that's the only music I'll exercise to :) You'd be running around screaming and holding your ears, probably chasing me with a knife to make me give you the stereo remote lmao!


bdsbabydoll

Attention everyone! Please enforce the crickets! Please enforce the crickets! Let's open the door so the roach can get out and go play somewhere else


TheKey

I agree brown-skin. I luv'd Aaliyah, but they have completely different styles of singing. I think Beyonce has more range and versatility voice-wise. Beyonce's voice is too powerful for One in a million.


TheKey

*crick-it* *crick-it*


brown_skin

You couldn't have said it better TheKey

Bsbabydoll: Just ignore that fool he or she is looking for attention.


MzMuffin03

i think people are really trippin why get mad at it?? yea the original version was great but let her do her remix lol

people do it with biggie and 2pac (my love) all the time no one gets all mad and say (oh my god they didnt not miss up pac song) lol i just find it funny female always lookin for a way to bring each other down i love bey she can work the song but i really feel like she wants is doin it for aaliyah :)


TheKey

thank you brown.

@msmuffin03

I'm not mad. U might have a point with the biggie tupac stuff, but i think that's more taking bits and pieces of the songs or beats. my problem is not that she'll mess up the song, but that she might sing the hell out of it which is exactly what Aaliyah didn't do. Aaliyah had a very soft and mellow feel to her songs(which isn't a bad thing), unlike the forceful and loud "ring the alarm" feel beyonce has.


MrsSJackson

Hold on, time out, flag on the play....

Jagged Edge did a Jodeci remake?? Where the hell was I?


KEKE01

Has it been 10 years since that song came out?? I am so sick of the yella chic aka beynonce!


Ieshialicious

I have nothing against Beyonce she's a great entertainer, but she needs to leave one in a million as is.


gingergirl

I'm starting to despise Bey. She's been way overexposed years ago. Does she have to be in everything, everywhere? world tours and such. Her voice is alright but it grates on my nerves and her doe eyed azz is a pest. Even on commercials now too. I think her freaky daddy is a freak. She never wants to be out of the public eye ever and who cares about she and J anymore? there is such a thing as overexposure and thats Bey. Her acting is medicore no matter how many movies she makes. Notice Tyler Perry didnt invite her to play in any of his movies which are big hits. I think she's stuck on herself and I used to like her back in the bills, bills days but not anymore. Everyone doesnt have to be a fan nor are we jealous of her success, its just how we feel some of us. Aaliyah was who she was and doesnt need to be copied. Loved her in Romeo must die


TheKey

*** gingergirl. it'll be ok. I don't think beyonce wanted to be overexposed the way she is. i mean she's always tried to have the media focus on her career instead of her relationship. but "we" as the public are nosy as hell which is why gossip sites and paps are in existence. my thing is you don't have to be a fan, but you don't have to be a hater either.


QueenNisha

I'm going to be honest on this one. Yes Beyonce is getting too much exposure but you can't blame a girl for making her money. In my opinion, she is more talented than Aaliyah was. Her voice is stronger and her game is fierce. I loved Aaliyah too but her vocals matched Ciara's. All three can dance their assess off, We know two could act, All three are beautiful but when it comes to voices, Beyonce wins hands down. I have mad respect for all three though.

RIP Aaliyah


tashianash

Looks-aaliyah hands down. Vocals-beyonce